Ingredients
Method
Start cold:
- Place a small pan on the stove cold. Add the olive oil and the sliced garlic.
Warm slowly:
- Heat on low. Let the garlic soften until translucent but never brown. Stir often.
Prepare anchovies:
- If using salted anchovies, soak them 10–20 minutes in cool water, rinse, pat dry, and remove bones. Jarred fillets can go in as is.
Melt anchovies into oil:
- Add the anchovies to the warm garlic oil. Use the back of a spoon to mash them until they dissolve into the oil and form a smooth sauce.
Gentle simmer:
- Keep the heat low. Do not fry or sizzle. Let the mixture gently bubble for 5–10 minutes. Add a splash more oil if it tightens.
Finish the sauce:
- Remove from direct heat and stir in a small pat of butter. Add a splash of cream only if you prefer the creamier modern style.
Serve warm:
- Pour the sauce into a terracotta pot, fondue pot, or small vessel that can stay warm with a candle or low flame.
Enjoy:
- Dip fresh vegetables, crusty bread, or soft polenta. Keep the sauce warm but never hot enough to fry.
Notes
- Keep the heat gentle from start to finish. High heat ruins the flavor.
- Use the best anchovies you can find. They make the biggest difference.
- If someone is sensitive to garlic, you can simmer the cloves in milk first or roast whole heads for a sweeter flavor.
- Leftovers keep 2–3 days in the fridge. Reheat very slowly so the oil and garlic don’t fry.
- The leftover “spesso” (thicker bits at the bottom) is gold: stir into eggs, pasta, or spread on pizza dough before baking.
